Secondary metabolites play a key role in mediating pollination and plant defense against herbivory. One such metabolite, methyl anthranilate, is a volatile compound responsible for the recognizable scent of Concord grapes. Methyl anthranilate is commercially used as a bird repellent for golf courses and as a flavoring agent for grape-flavored foods, beverages, and pharmaceuticals. A variety of plant species such as Zea mays (maize) and Vitis labrusca (fox grape) synthesize methyl anthranilate from anthranilate, an intermediate in tryptophan biosynthesis. Methyl anthranilate biosynthesis is a classic example of convergent evolution; in maize, this reaction is catalyzed by an anthranilate methyltransferase (AAMT1), while in grape, there is a two-step pathway. Previous studies have found that the ZmAAMT1 SABATH methyltransferase likely evolved from methyltransferases that recognize the plant pathogen response hormone salicylic acid as a substrate. Using site-directed mutagenesis, we introduced 12 independent missense mutations at 7 key active site residues with the intention of restoring substrate specificity for salicylic acid. This work will allow us to better trace and understand the evolution of anthranilate-derived specialized metabolism in plants.